Sizzle: a global warming comedy

| 0 Comments | 7 TrackBacks | View blog reactions
Two years ago Randy Olson brought us Flock of Dodos, which examined the debate between those who think intelligent design creationism should be included in school science curricula and those who don't.1 The film makes a powerful case that we, i.e. evolutionists, are part of the reason that intelligent design creationism has been so successful. Proponents of ID connect with people in ways that we don't. Sizzle argues that scientists are part of the reason that that climate skeptics have been so successful.

Let me clear. By "successful" I don't mean "successful in raising challenges that affect the overwhelming scientific consensus." I mean "successful in raising challenges that allow non-scientists to think that there are credible reasons to doubt the consensus." Proponents of ID and climate skeptics seem like nice, ordinary people. They talk in language that other ordinary people can understand. We talk like scientists, because we are.

After a production meeting in which Randy proposes a PowerPoint presentation for the movie because his cameraman kept interrupting and ruining the interviews,1 his mother (Muffy Moose) sneaks out of the meeting with his cameraman and soundman for a night on the town. They tell her that Randy's movie is in trouble, and she tells Randy that he needs to listen to them. Soon they're off to New Orleans and the lower 9th ward to see how the richest country in the world recovers from a disaster.

zpq0510787460003.jpegSummary of 21st century socioclimatic exposure (from Diffenbaugh et al.; view larger image in a popup window)
Randy has a Ph.D. in marine biology. He's smart enough to know that (a) the connection between any single weather event and climate change is very indirect and tenuous and (b) there is (so far as I can tell) still legitimate debate about the extent to which climate change will increase the frequency and severity of hurricanes.2 But the visit to the lower 9th ward is the most powerful part of the movie. It brings home the impact that global climate change could have on us, particularly when I read on Sunday yet another sign of Katrina fatigue: a memorial planned for the victims of Katrina is stalled. Colorful maps like the one to the left persuade me that we have a problem, but even though I'm a science geek,3 I find film from the lower 9th ward more emotionally compelling.
Sizzle premieres this Saturday at Outfest in Los Angeles. On the following Saturday it will be shown in my own back yard as the opening night film for the Woods Hole Film Festival, with a panel discussion to follow on Sunday. I won't be able to attend,4 but I hope to add UConn to the list of universities at which screenings are planned. Get yourself to a theater where it's showing. Encourage a college, university, or museum in your area to show it. And in the meantime, enjoy the trailer...
1Of course we know that he had things planned this way all along, but still the conceit works nicely. (Notice the "non-ordinary person" writing there - "conceit" used in a phrase where it doesn't mean "stuck up", and the whole thing buried in a footnote. Sorry. I am what I am.)
2There isn't much debate about whether extreme weather events will become more common. They will. the IPCC synthesis report concluded that
  • it is very likely we'll see increases in the frequency of heat waves and heavy precipitation,
  • it is likely we'll see more tropical cyclones, i.e., hurricanes, and
  • there is high confidence that many arid and semi-arid areas will have fewer water resources than they do now.
3Areas in dark red are the in which 21st century climate change is expected to have the greatest impact. And yes, the eastern coast of the United States is colored the same dark red as Bangladesh.
4I'll be in Vancouver, BC for Botany 2008.

7 TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://darwin.eeb.uconn.edu/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1668

Sizzle Tuesday from Uncommon Ground on July 15, 2008 10:53 AM

If you're interested in other reviews of Sizzle, there's a long list of them (some good, some not so good) at ScienceBlogs.com.... Read More

In "Sizzle" Randy Olson asks three questions: (1) Has the earth warmed over the last century and a half? (2) Are human activities responsible for a large part of that warming? (3) Can we do anything to stop it? Anyone... Read More

Sizzle in Nature from Uncommon Ground on July 18, 2008 2:15 PM

Emma Marris didn't much like "Sizzle"Ultimately, one is left wondering what the film aims to do. Does it argue that climate change is real, or discuss how we might convince people that it is? At the end of the film,... Read More

"Swindle" in breach from Uncommon Ground on July 22, 2008 7:48 AM

On 8 March 2007 a documentary called "The Great Global Warming Swindle" premiered on Britain's Channel 4.The film takes a strongly sceptical view of current scientific thinking on climate change. It argues that the consensus on climate change is the... Read More

Gavin at RealClimate.org points to a two-part series by Curtis Brainard in the Columbia Journalism Review, "Public opinion and climate" (part 1, part 2). I encourage you to read the whole thing, but Brainard makes several especially important points.[T... Read More

Empty oceans from Uncommon Ground on September 30, 2008 10:34 AM

Randy Olson, producer of Flock of Dodos and Sizzle, has a new short video out illustrating how much the oceans have changed in the last fifty years. The evidence from personal reflections on two raft trips is anecdotal, but... Read More

Randy Olson (marine scientist and producer/director of Flock of Dodos and Sizzle) has a book coming out in September. Here's a bit of the blurb from his publisher (Island Press):"Don't Be Such a Scientist: Talking Substance in an Age of... Read More

Leave a comment

 Subscribe in a reader

Recent Entries

Don't be such a scientist
Randy Olson (marine scientist and producer/director of Flock of Dodos and Sizzle) has a book coming out in September. Here's…
Swartberg Pass
We (Jane, Bronwen, Chris, and I) left Capetown on Sunday, May 17 for Robinson's Pass (between Mossel Bay and Oudtshoorn).…
Wednesday's trip
On Wednesday we (Jane, Chris, and I) drove to Jonaskop to check out plants in our experimental garden there, and…
Nature Blog Network View blog authority